A price tag is not a promise: offer and acceptance in two small-business disputes

Contract law can feel remote from accounting until you remember what an accountant or auditor is often checking: did this sale actually happen, at this price, on this date? Those are questions about whether a contract exists.
For a Business and Company Law assignment I had to advise a small business owner who sells and repairs IT devices. Two customers each believed they had a binding contract with him. In both cases, I concluded they did not.
The basics
A contract is a legally binding agreement. For one to exist there must be an offer, an acceptance of that offer, an intention to create legal relations, and compliance with any legal requirements. Both disputes turned on the first two.
Dispute 1: the wrong price tag
A reconditioned tablet was displayed with a £100 price label. At the till, the owner realised the correct price was £200. The customer insisted on paying £100.
Is the shop bound by the label? No.
Goods on display are not an offer. They are an invitation to treat: an invitation for the customer to make an offer, which the shop can accept or refuse.
Two cases establish this:
- Fisher v Bell (1961). A shopkeeper displayed a flick knife in his window with a price ticket and was prosecuted for "offering for sale" a prohibited weapon. The court held that displaying goods is an invitation to treat, not an offer.
- Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots (1953). In a self-service shop, the customer makes the offer by taking goods to the till. The contract is formed when the cashier accepts.
Applied here: the customer made an offer to buy at £100 when they brought the tablet to the till. The owner was free to refuse it. No acceptance, no contract.
There is a second reason. In Hartog v Colin & Shields (1939), a seller made an obvious mistake when quoting a price, and the buyer tried to hold him to it. The court refused: a buyer cannot snap up an offer they must have known was a mistake. Even if the label had counted as an offer, a customer who has been told the price is wrong cannot insist on it.
Dispute 2: the late letter
On 21 July the owner offered to sell a reconditioned iPhone 14 to a trader for £500, stating "notice in writing required by 28th July". The trader posted his acceptance on 22 July. It did not arrive until 30 July. Having heard nothing, the owner had sold the phone to his sister on 29 July. The trader claimed breach of contract.
This is harder, because of the postal rule.
- Adams v Lindsell (1818) established that when acceptance is sent by post, it takes effect when the letter is posted, not when it arrives. On that rule alone, a contract existed from 22 July, and selling to someone else would be a breach.
But the rule has limits.
- Holwell Securities v Hughes (1974). An option had to be exercised by "notice in writing" to the other party. The letter was posted but never arrived. The court held that the wording required the acceptance to actually be received, which displaced the postal rule.
The owner's offer used almost the same wording. By requiring notice in writing by a date, he made receipt a condition. The letter arrived two days after the deadline, so there was no valid acceptance and no contract. He was free to sell the phone.
The advice
In both cases the business owner was in the stronger legal position:
- The price label was an invitation to treat, and he was entitled to refuse the customer's offer.
- The acceptance did not reach him by the deadline he had set, so the postal rule did not apply.
Why this matters outside a law exam
Three things carry over into finance work.
Timing. When a contract is formed decides which period a transaction belongs to. Whether acceptance counts on posting or on receipt is exactly the kind of detail that matters for cut-off at a period end.
Wording. One phrase, "notice in writing required by", changed the outcome. The same is true of any agreement a finance team relies on, from a tenancy to a supplier contract: the position depends on what the document actually says, not on what either side assumed.
Evidence. The owner's position was strong because his offer was in writing with a clear deadline. A good paper trail is a control, and it is the reason reviewing files for completeness matters.
Based on an assignment I wrote during my BA (Hons) Accounting and Finance at the University of Greenwich. This is a student's summary of general principles of English contract law, not legal advice.